The 3-Option Principle in Design

When presenting your first delivery to a client, how many options do you usually provide? And more importantly, what's your strategy behind those options to help clients make decisions and move towards the final design more efficiently?

I've heard that many designers follow a formula that looks something like this:

Very Good – Very Bad – Fine

The first option is your very good one. This is where you put 100% of your passion, creativity, and intellectual effort. Naturally, this is also the option you secretly hope your client will choose.

The second option is the very bad one. It's an option you don't particularly like, sometimes even one you intentionally include to make sure the client doesn't choose it. But at least, it adds some variety to the presentation.

The third option is fine. It's still a good design, and you'll be happy if the client chooses it, but perhaps not as happy as you would be with the first one.

Personally, I think this is a rather risky approach.

If the client chooses your very good option, great. There's no problem at all. But when clients see all three options side by side, they're not just evaluating the designs individually. They're also evaluating your consistency and creative capabilities as a designer.

Now, imagine your client actually prefers the option you consider very bad.

What happens then?

You'll still have to move forward with the project, but you might lose some of the excitement you had at the beginning. Deep down, you know this isn't the direction you're particularly passionate about. You might even hesitate when deciding whether to include the project in your portfolio later.

So, what's a better way to approach the 3-option strategy, one that helps both you and your client move through the project more smoothly?

After 10 years in the industry, I've developed a formula that works well for me:

Strictly Follow the Brief – Put Your Taste – The Balance

I don't see these as three different levels of quality. Instead, they're three different approaches to solving the same design problem.

The most important thing is that all three options should be designs you're genuinely proud to present. Whichever one the client chooses, you should feel equally confident and excited to develop it further.

1. Strictly Follow the Brief – Give Them What They Asked For.

For the first option, I focus on solving the brief as directly and accurately as possible.

I put myself in the client's shoes, understand what they're looking for, and translate their requirements into a design that reflects exactly what they want to see.

There's no need to experiment too much or go too far beyond the brief. The goal is to demonstrate that you understand the problem and know how to solve it effectively.

2. Put Your Taste – Give Them What They Didn't Know They Wanted.

This is where you bring your personality, experience, and creative perspective into the project.

Instead of simply following what the client asks for, you ask yourself: If I had the freedom to suggest a direction that I genuinely believe would be better for the brand, what would it look like?

It could be a new visual direction, a different approach, or an idea the client has never considered before.

Sometimes, this is the option that creates the most exciting moment during a presentation, when the client looks at your design and realizes there's a possibility they hadn't thought of.

That's the value a designer brings to the table: Not just executing what's requested, but opening up new possibilities.

3. The Balance – Find Another Possibility.

The third option gives you more room to explore.

You can combine the strengths of the first two approaches to create something new. Or you can take a completely different direction, something more experimental, expressive, and outside the box.

I like to think of this option as an opportunity to explore another possibility within the brief, rather than simply creating a middle ground between the first two options.

With this approach, there's one thing I always try to maintain: All three options must have an equally high level of design quality.

Each option should have its own point of view, its own logic, and its own way of solving the brief. But none of them should exist merely to make another option look better.

Because I believe that when clients see three equally strong directions, they get a much better understanding of your capabilities as a designer.

They see that you can follow a brief, bring your own perspective, and explore new creative possibilities. More importantly, they can feel that you're genuinely invested in their project, rather than simply producing a few variations to complete a step in the design process.

And the best part? You don't have to emotionally invest everything in just one option. Whichever direction the client chooses, you'll have the confidence and enthusiasm to develop it into something great.

To me, presenting three options isn't simply about giving clients three designs to choose from. It's an opportunity to demonstrate your thinking, personality, and creative capabilities from the very first delivery.

Don't create options to influence your client's choice. Create options to show them what you're capable of.

Next
Next

9 Special Inks and Printing Effects You Should Know About